Friday, 9 March 2012

The more choice the better: Yes, no or maybe? (extension)


Hi folks here is an update from our first blog. We have found an article that might quite answer the thought that is flowing through most of your minds. Is too much really too good or is it just a flop. Entitled in the blog are some personal replies we have commented for some of you whom have posted us a few questions. Once again we thank you for being an avid reader and supporter on our web blog and we hope to bring your more post and sharing along the way as journey through the semester.

Through this article that was published on the New York Times, it shows how studies were done to show the effects of consumer’s paralysis and how overwhelming choices drive consumers away. Empirical studies have found that people, regardless of intelligence, do not always choose well. Often they prefer to let inertia take over, unable or unwilling to choose for themselves. Well in fact we would like to highlight how three experiments were done when too many choices were being given to individuals like ourselves as consumers.

Case-study 1:
In Sweden, where personal savings accounts were carved out of the social security system in 1998, 9 out of 10 new entrants to the work force let their investment portfolios go to a default fund set up by the government, rather than choose one themselves.

Case-study 2:
Too many options may drive consumers away. In one experiment, Iyengar of Columbia University found that people who had been shown a selection of six jams in a store were about 10 times as likely to buy a jar as those exposed to a range of 24 flavors.

Case-study 3:
In another study, she found that people who chose one chocolate from a selection of 30 expressed more regret and uncertainty about their decision than those who chose among six kinds. That's because, with 29 other options, there is a bigger chance of losing out on something better.

Case-study 4:
In one experiment, Thaler and Shlomo Benartzi of the University of California at Los Angeles, asked employees in one company to select among three 401(k) retirement savings portfolios. Unknown to the employees, one portfolio was their own. The other two reflected the average and median choices of all the workers in the company. Yet only one-fifth of the employees preferred their own portfolios to the medians. "Apparently people do not gain much by choosing investment portfolios for themselves," Thaler wrote.


Take a look at the video below, though this video share with us viewers about the trade secrets in a supermarket but we want you to take a good look of the array of choices we are exposed to just by visiting a supermarket today. How confused we are or how troubled we are in making just a simple purchase on a fizzy drink!


The second video entitled here is called the paradox of choice which some of you may be looking for, from the very man who wrote it Barry Schwartz: 


Sources:
1. The more choice the better: Yes, no or maybe?
2. Barry Schwartz- paradox of choice (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VO6XEQIsCoM)

We hope this update would have answered most of your questions and we look forward to hear more from you folks so stay tune for more updates. Below are our replies to the few individuals who have pop us a question.

51487735 LONER
Hi 51487735Loner from one and all at JARSolutionz we thank you for reading and providing insightful details from a businessman perspective. Well yes we do agree that as a business entity it is important to stand out from your competitors. To stand up and shine at the occasion, it is necessary to be different but not necessarily providing extended choices. Well as much you touch base from a businessman perspective, I guess as a business person you need to know what your consumer need or want in your targeted market segment. Therefore, providing more choices may sometimes do more harm than good, in short detrimental spiral effects.

If we may refer to the link which you have provided:

What could be understood from Cathay’s offering is that they streamline their Asia Miles points to four different categories; first class, business class, premium economy class, economy class. This offering of choice actually helps consumers avoid the hassle of decision making. In fact it is rather straight forward, if you fly in a particular class you earn X number of Miles points and yes at the same time they use the technology of internet to market their system. Therefore through this system Cathay has indeed help consumers understand their system by minimising their offering of choices.

40040157 CYNICAL
Hi Cynical we had great fun reading your comments and you have set us thinking certainly. If we may refer to your comment, you mentioned about nobody dictates the right choice and the choice made does not necessarily suit the consumer. Yes certainly nobody dictates our choices as consumers. As a consumer we perceive what suits us best and that’s the most important. What may suit you may not suit me.

Next you mentioned through globalisation we boost our choices and if we make a wrong one we could always make another. Well we back to differ, if we lose a customer because of the wide array of choices we offer which cause such confusion, we may be losing much more money. It actually cost more opportunity cost of losing a customer then winning one. Coupled with you mentioning that today’s consumers are well informed and educated, what are your chances of retaining your customers if you don’t ever streamline your offerings/choices today? Now that we may understand what consumers want, we are not saying that we do not give them a choice but we streamline the choices, helping them to affirm their decisions, thus answering the question of consumer paralysis.




Hey international blogger thank you for providing your thoughts about our article. You mentioned that the more products there are on the market, the better it is for consumers as prices will be kept low. Well having a wide array of choices does not necessarily mean prices will be kept low; we reckon you may be giving the example of bulk offering which gives a comparable low pricing or better offers. We have to be very careful between array of choices compared to bulk discount because having a large array of choices for example cheese do certainly keep each branding competitive on how they market their prices but that does not mean they mark down their pricing.

Let’s look at the offering of cheese by Park &shop:

If we take a look at PHILADELPHIA CREAM CHEESE and Boursin cream cheese both are of the same category, so if we adopt your theory of saying more choice would mean cheaper pricing, we guess your deduction may be out of line. Boursin in this case has a strong competitor-ship of not only Philadelphia cheese but also rival competitors like Arla and Laughing Cow brands but their pricing of their product still maintains the highest. Therefore we hope that our explanation would help you see in better alignment how too many choices may cloud a consumer’s decision and not give bulk discounts instead J
Hey MusicLover interesting question which you have highlighted. We think it would be hard to limit the choice in a free market concept. If you would to recall the above article which we recommend:


As mention in the article, free marketers believed that wide choices is the positive notion for us consumers but certainly the experiments conducted from the range from a simple food choice to a financial choice decision; certainly  proves that too many options would certainly drive consumers away.

Hi 40038229 we heard your call for a reference to understand more about Consumer’s paralysis. The link mentioned above would certainly address your dire thoughts about the topic.




Wednesday, 1 February 2012

Global Myth: "More is Less"

<><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><> <> <> <><><><><><><><> <><><><><><><><><><> <><><><><><><><><><><><><><> <> <> <><><><><><><><> <><><><><><><><><><> <><><><><><><><><><><><><><> <><>

 




    The first thing you do every single day of your life when you wake up is to choose. You have to choose to either hit the snooze button or kick off the sheets and start your day. You’ll eventually drag yourself off the bed, only to face more choices; which type of toothpaste should you use? Should you drink coffee or the healthier orange juice? Will you wear shorts, or pants? If you opt for the shorts, what color? What flavor of cereal should you eat? You make choice after choice, and the perpetual decision making is inescapable throughout the day, until the moment you slip back into bed and into dreamy oblivion.

But not every choice we make is as simple as choosing between the few types of morning beverages in your refrigerator. As the world takes a huge step further through globalization, we find ourselves having to make increasingly more choices. We are now exposed to a colossal spectrum of products, and more goods and services are available than ever before. As the world as our supermarket, we expect and demand seemingly unlimited variety and choice in not only consumer goods but also education, medical services, and even cultures and religions. It initially seems intuitively appealing on a personal note to be indulged in such a colorful variety of choices, each with their own perks. We automatically associate choices with increased consumer power and control, more freedom, and ultimately, happiness. We have slowly become mechanically dependant on ample choices to bring us utility or at least seemed to have convinced ourselves so. This central dogma, sprouting from the illusion of the association of choices with freedom and happiness, could not be further from the truth. Contrary to this slippery and seemingly convincing myth that “more is more” whereby people believe that their welfare will only get better with marginal choices, the evidence points to the inconvenient truth that “more is less”, where there comes a point where additional choices actually stifle consumer freedom and make each of us more miserable about the choices that we are forced to make.  






We first have to explore the grand orchestrator that made it possible to have such a dizzying catalogue of goods; globalization. The phenomenon of globalization transformed our world to be smaller and more accessible. Products that could once only be purchased at the place of origin, such as silk, are now available in other countries, through trade and exploitation of comparative advantages. The sheer amount of choices that a consumer would face at a typical grocery store is staggering; on average, he will choose between 285 types of cookies, 75 types of ice tea, 230 types of soup and 175 different types of salad dressings. There are several factors that contribute to the fact that consumers



One of the factors leads globalization is free trade agreement between countries. FTA is a good example of how free trade between countries would maximize the choices of products in each country. 41 percent of the U.S. goods produced were exported to FTA partner countries in 2010 at growing rate.(International Trade Administration, 2011) For instance, NAFTA (North American Free Trade Agreement) removed the major trade barriers and tariffs between Canada, U.S. and Mexico. This means that consumers in Mexico could easily purchase American goods without paying higher price, which implies that the foreign goods would gain the competitive power over some local goods. Because of this reason, selling foreign goods became more profitable which creates the increase in supply. The mixture of local and imported goods can provide more variety of products in choice.

Another facilitator of choice is the wide usage of internet shopping and electronic commerce. E-commerce is one of the fastest growing industries which led the increase in economic and market globalization.(B.2010) Many people purchase products online. It provides discounted prices and convenience in reduction of time. Also, due to innovation of transportation, the internet became a perfect tool for foreign consumers to purchase local goods. This process makes the customers have bigger choices to look over when they attempt to make purchase.

Also, changing in life styles can be one of the factors. Different lifestyle leads different demand in products. As nations get closer, different cultures spread like fire. In many Asian cultures, people have adapted a western lifestyle through the influence of media, expatriates, and the market. The change increases the demand of imported goods which would fit in their new lifestyle. Recently in China, consumption of western lifestyle goods is continually growing among high and upper class locals. Many consumers demand western lifestyle products such as organic foods, wine, cheese and similar high-end products. These products were originally designed to target expatriates, but now they are more popular among Chinese customers. To meet the contemporary needs, some stores carry 70-80% imported goods. (Leanne, May, &Tong, 2011) The imported goods add to aisles in supermarket and become one of the choices for the customers.

As a product of open-market competition, trade blocs and a shift toward a global standard, globalization has diversified the markets at unprecedented levels, throwing consumers into the tempest of choices. Despite the current misconception that this increase in choices maximizes human welfare, the levels of choice modern day consumers face as a result of globalization actually have an adverse affect on people in a variety of ways.

One way in which this occurs is through the form of “consumer paralysis”. This is when the consumer is faced with such an overwhelming amount of choice that they refrain from making any choice at all. This can be a common symptom in areas where consumers are forced to make decisions regarding health insurance and pension plans where there are a large number of variables in decisions that have high influence in a consumer’s everyday life.

According to ‘The paradox of choice’ by Barry Schwartz, the creation of more and more choice also reduces customer satisfaction in a number of different ways.
 The first way is that with the existence of increased choice, it becomes easier for the consumer to imagine that there was probably an alternative choice that may have been better. This enduces them to regret their choice even if it was a good one.

Another possible reason for the reduction in post-purchase customer satisfaction can be derived from the concept of ‘opportunity cost’. This makes it easier for the consumer to be nagged by the attractive features of the alternatives they could have chosen. It is human nature to desire and imagine the best possible outcome in a situation. Through the increased choice that globalization creates however, it becomes even easier for the consumers to imagine the things that they are missing out on, which in turn drains the level of satisfaction they walk away from each decision.





Furthermore, choice satisfaction is further diminished by the increase in customer expectations. For example, decades ago when you could only buy one type of jeans, customers would walk away from the store with a pair that might not fit great, but with a smile on their face. Now, with thousands of different types and brands available, a customer can walk into a shop and try lots of styles and walk away with a better fitting pair. Despite this, their customer satisfaction is lower as with so much to choose from they expect to walk away with a perfect fitting pair - when all they got was good. Despite getting a better product, the consumer is less satisfied as a result of the amount of choice available to them.

The reason why "everything was better back when everything was worse is that when everything was worse it was actually possible for people to have experiences that were a pleasant surprise" (Barry Schwartz, The Paradox of Choice, 2004)

Perhaps the most convincing argument within the paradox of choice lies masked in the theme of blame. For instance, if a consumer makes a poor choice in an environment where there is little choice available, they believe the blame to fall on the world surrounding them, as sufficient choice was not provided. When the consumer makes a poor decision in an environment that provides them with extensive choice however, the consumer blames themselves. This concept of self-blame has an adverse effect on us psychologically and can deteriorate our self esteem and often throw consumers into depression.


Whether we chose it or not, globalization has thrown us all into a smaller, more crowded and ever more paradoxical and confusing world. At the swipe of an iPhone, or by simply walking into the town mall, we are hit by a tidal wave of choices that slowly and obscurely overwhelm us. Globalization has very literally shrunk the globe, putting goods, services, cultures, animals, trends and even ideas at our “leisurely” disposal if ever we would choose to have them. The “Silk Road”, having transformed itself into the internet and worldwide trade and logistics, has engulfed the world like a spider web, throwing producers onto the world market to procure an infinite array of choices to satiate our gluttonous consumerism and meet our ever-high expectations. As the entire world as our shopping mall, we as consumers, choose not to settle for anything but the best.

As self-proclaimed “global citizens”, we try to make sense of this maelstrom of choice and confusion by convincing ourselves that “this is good, it’s how it’s supposed to be”. We are all entrapped by the central dogma that asserts that more choices leads to more freedom and freedom will make us all happier.

… Right?

What could be better than having the “freedom” to choose between 342 different kinds of chocolate or 321 brands of shampoo? Probabilistically speaking, more choice means that there is a higher chance that at least one of those choices will be the perfect chocolate bar or shampoo, and everybody knows that good chocolate makes you happy. But ironically, instead of liberation, the thick, daunting catalogue has turned us into the most picky, miserable and materialistic generation in history. Through “Consumer Paralysis”, diminished happiness from our ultimate choices, the nagging thought of opportunity costs foregone from the 1349 other choices you could have made, and just the sheer stress of making decisions after decisions, when the fog clears at the end of the day, it turns out that more is not more, but less. Although we have more options to choose from then ever, we are considerably less happy about the choices that we make as we sit at the tippy top of the “diminishing marginally utility curve”.

So what, then, should we do? How should we, as already demanding consumers, deal with the demoralizing truth that the sense of security we felt as we looked at the endless list of foreign brands and choices was actually an illusion? The first step we could take is to realize that not every choice we make needs to be perfect. Buying the wrong type of orange juice will not yield unfortunate and life-long effects. We need to learn to be less demanding on ourselves and the producers to meet our every meticulous needs and wants. We also need to be more aware of the sway and influence that marketing and familiarity has on our choices, and realize that we actually do not need a lot of the things that we own or buy. Eliminating these useless choices will make our lives a lot easier and economic. Although this paradox of choice can often confuse and leave consumers in doldrums, we have to understand that underneath this conundrum lays a blessing. This paradox is a side-effect of economic prosperity, and only exists in affluent developed countries. There are still plenty consumers in poorer countries who would benefit greatly from more choices. So although our complex, globalized world may at times seem contradictory and confusing amongst the infinite choices, we have to be grateful for what we have and stay aware so that we may not fall victim to the hands of the paradox of choice.






Reference


B. Katalinic. (2010). Electronic Commerce within the Context of Globalization, Annals of DAAAM for 2010. 21(1). 1726-9679. 727.
International Trade Administration. Free Trade Agreement. Retrieved from http://trade.gov/fta/


Leanne Wang, May L., &Tong W.(2011). China Retail Annual Report (GAIN Report number: CH0816). Shanghai, China. Shanghai ATO.


The Paradox of Choice (n.d.). In Wikipedia. Retrieved February 1, 2012, from http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Paradox_of_Choice:_Why_More_Is_Less

Friday, 20 January 2012

JARSolutions





Hi! we are JARSolutionz. We are a diverse group from different cultures and nationalities, but through the process of "globalization." Our blogs represent our thoughts on subjects such as globalization and international management as an intergral part of the curriculum of our course, MGT 4221. Here is a brief introduction of each of our group members.


Jeremiah Koh:Born and breed in Singapore, come from a family of 4. Loves the sunny weather back home but the TIM SUM in Hong Kong is captivating his hungry soul. Loves hot cars, like the Maseratti, Lamborgini and Audii. Finds Hong Kong a messy pile but yet within the messiness is the simplicity of life, culture and good dinning.IF you love food, you love me:)
Alex Kwon: born in Korea but spent 6 years in U.S.,in love with city, but spent most of my American life in middle of corn field or no where, love eating good food, sleeping, and meeting new people, so, please say hi. I don't bite:)

Ross Coulter: Born in Glasgow, Scotland in 1990. Attended Hutchesons' Grammar School then went to Strathclyde University. Have worked and lived in many locations around the world, including Honduras, California, Spain and now Hong Kong..
Sam Lee: A self-proclaimed organic product of globalization, born in Korea but moved away to Cairo, Egypt at the age of 8. After a year in Egypt, I spent the majority of my life in Macao SAR, though ultimately failing to learn Cantonese successfully assimilate. Currently residing in Hong Kong city, and lovin' life. Favorite McDonalds meal: number 5.